Are the tradition wars altering how Christian college students select schools?

(RNS) — As of late, politics can affect every thing from the dairy merchandise you eat (Ben & Jerry’s? Chick-fil-A milkshake?) as to whether you drink Pepsi or Coke. For some Christian households, politics are additionally revamping the school choice course of, swaying them away from schools marked “too liberal” or “too conservative.”

Although there are Protestant schools that welcome political labels, others try to stay as apolitical as doable. For the latter, it’s an rising problem to protect their non secular id — which invariably has political implications in immediately’s supercharged atmosphere — whereas welcoming college students of all political backgrounds.

Ruth Curran Neild. Courtesy of SREE

“I feel Christians are discipled by political debates generally greater than they’re actually discipled by Christ or Christianity,” stated Ruth Curran Neild, whose son lately withdrew from Grove Metropolis School in Grove Metropolis, Pennsylvania, over considerations concerning the faculty’s politics.  

Final yr, the school was mired in a tradition conflict debate over whether or not the conservative faculty had promoted essential race idea. A extremely contentious board-approved report dominated it had.

“I noticed the report come again from sub-committee, and I used to be gob smacked” stated Neild, whose son had dedicated to the school in early November 2021. In her view, the board had taken the bait and engaged what she noticed as a manufactured disaster over an ultra-conservative boogeyman.

“I believed they did not need to hearken to real cries of ache from marginalized communities,” stated Neild. “It wasn’t grounded in shared Christian beliefs — it was on the degree of politics.”

Neild, who lives in New Jersey and belongs to a Presbyterian Church in America congregation, informed RNS that originally Grove Metropolis’s location, Christian id and powerful pc science program made it appear to be a simple match. However the board’s choice led to a household dialog in Might, and, after a lot thought, Neild stated her son opted for Messiah School, a faculty in Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, the household perceived as extra politically impartial.

Whereas a number of dad and mom who spoke to RNS for this story stated they’d tried to steer college students away from Christian faculties that “embrace MAGA,” as one mom put it, different dad and mom voiced an opposing concern: They apprehensive about what they noticed as an encroachment of liberal values on conventional non secular beliefs.

Amy Miller, who lives close to Philadelphia and likewise attends a PCA church, informed RNS her son transferred to Liberty College in Lynchburg, Virginia, this yr from Muhlenberg School, a liberal arts faculty in Allentown, Pennsylvania.

Liberty College campus in Lynchburg, Virginia. Picture by Lukas Souza/Unsplash/Artistic Commons

Miller stated the change was associated to Liberty’s reserve officers’ coaching corps program and its “conservative, Bible believing” Christian tradition. She described Liberty as “refreshing” and as an “oasis,” the place college students might be bolstered of their Christ-centered beliefs earlier than being every day bombarded by opposing worldviews.

“That’s why I’d undoubtedly push all the remainder of my children to Christian schools,” stated Miller, who expressed concern for a way the broader tradition approached questions associated to gender and sexuality. Miller additionally famous not all Christian schools could be a great match for her household. “I feel Wheaton School, my husband would say our youngsters can’t go there as a result of he thinks that they’re a bit bit extra liberal.”

John Fea, professor of American historical past at Messiah School, believes there’s a widening rift within the Christian faculty panorama between evangelical schools open to political and, in some circumstances, theological range and people who embrace a uniformly conservative id.  

“You see actually conservative evangelicals who would have supported Trump, who questioned vaccine and masks mandates, who’re apprehensive about essential race idea, gravitating towards your Liberties, Hillsdales and Cedarvilles in some respect. I feel it’s going to create a cut up.”

It’s not stunning that politics have develop into a think about some Christians’ faculty calculations, given their rising affect on social interactions. An August NBC survey of over 1,000 rising faculty sophomores discovered that 62% of Democrats (and 28% of Republicans) stated they might not room with somebody who supported the alternative 2020 presidential candidate. Greater than half of all college students stated they both undoubtedly or most likely wouldn’t go on a date with an individual who supported the opposing candidate.

Leaders from Prism, OUTLaw, and SAFE Samford be a part of collectively for a gaggle photograph at Samford faculty. Picture by Lynn Smith

Political points also can earn Christian schools nationwide media consideration. Simply this final yr, Seattle Pacific College, Calvin College and Samford College made headlines for inner clashes over LGBTQ rights, whereas Grove Metropolis and Cornerstone College drew consideration for his or her method to race and racism.

At Seattle Pacific College in Seattle, Washington, college students staged sit-ins outdoors the president’s workplace this spring in response to a board vote that upheld the varsity’s hiring coverage requiring workers to “replicate a conventional view on Biblical marriage and sexuality.”

“We’ve got misplaced plenty of college students over that,” Michelle McFarland, director of enrollment companies at Seattle Pacific, informed RNS. “There are many welcoming areas right here for college students, nevertheless it was the illustration of school and employees the place they had been hoping to see the lived expertise of being homosexual and being a follower of Jesus.”

McFarland added that this yr, potential college students and their households had been extra more likely to ask concerning the faculty’s insurance policies round LGBTQ rights.

Based on Brianna Deters, a freshman nursing main at Calvin College in Grand Rapids, Michigan, politics are generally one of many first issues college students contemplate.

“It’s undoubtedly an element you have a look at within the college-decision course of. You see it’s a Christian faculty, after which instantly ask, what sort of Christian faculty is it?” stated Deters.

Although she’s solely been at Calvin a short time, she stated she already appreciates how Calvin engages with “sizzling subjects” from either side in chapels and different occasions.

Some students argue that whereas political divisions really feel new, older iterations have at all times embellished the Christian faculty panorama — rifts over evolution and biblical inerrancy, for instance, quite than over vaccines or essential race idea.

Silvio Vazquez, chief enrollment administration officer at Wheaton School. Picture courtesy of Wheaton School

Furthermore, admissions counselors from many of the seven Christian schools RNS related with for this story maintained that affordability stays potential college students’ prime precedence, not politics. And whereas some admissions representatives stated they’d seen a rise in political questions from potential college students, others, like Mary Herridge at Baylor College, stated politics nonetheless don’t appear to be a significant factor.

At Wheaton School, an evangelical faculty within the Chicago suburbs, Chief Enrollment Administration Officer Silvio Vazquez says he does typically encounter people who assume Wheaton is liberal or conservative. However he hopes college students received’t draw too many conclusions with out experiencing the varsity firsthand.

Amanda Staggenborg, chief communications officer for the Council for Christian Schools and Universities, a worldwide affiliation of greater than 180 Christian larger schooling establishments, informed RNS that when college students and their households make snap selections based mostly on a faculty’s perceived political id, they miss the large image.

“A college is manufactured from so many various issues, not only a label of conservative or progressive. You have got many various layers of teachers, social golf equipment and scholar life. You may’t label a complete college in that respect, as a result of everybody’s expertise may very well be completely different.”

Dr. Amanda Staggenborg, chief communications officer for the Council for Christian Schools & Universities. Courtesy CCCU

RELATED: School, college students sue Christian faculty over LGBTQ hiring ban

Isaac Willour, a junior political science main at Grove Metropolis, informed RNS that college students and fogeys have a proper to seek out schools that mirror their values. The issue arises, Willour stated, when schools enable political ideology to information tutorial inquiry and develop into “citadels” and “coaching camps” for creating “good little conservatives and good little liberals to exit and combat the tradition wars.”

“That’s not what faculty is meant to be.”

John Hawthorne, a retired sociologist who research faith, politics and better schooling, predicts that as youthful generations develop into much less non secular, potential college students might be extra more likely to keep away from Christian schools because of perceived political conservatism quite than perceived liberalism.

“There aren’t sufficient conservative dad and mom on the market to help all of the conservative faculties who need to present how conservative they’re,” stated Hawthorne. “Particularly amongst Gen Z, smaller and smaller percentages yearly are into these tougher, extra slim, right-wing stances.”

Mary Elizabeth Parker, a junior worldwide relations main at Samford School in Birmingham, Alabama, initially wished to attend a progressive, nonreligious faculty anyplace however her residence state.

Mary Elizabeth Parker, a world relations main at Samford School. Courtesy of Parker

“Particularly rising up being way more left leaning than the remainder of my friends, I believed the one technique to escape the evils I heard concerning the Republican Occasion and the pink states was to exit of state for college and by no means come again.”

When monetary challenges landed her on the Baptist College two hours away from the conservative group she was raised in, she cried for weeks. Years later, Parker says she’s the happiest she’s ever been. Now a campus tour information and vice chairman of Samford Democrats, Parker says she loves partaking in trustworthy tutorial dialogue about topics that matter, even — and maybe particularly — when she disagrees together with her friends.

“I’d say, in the event you do establish as a Christian, pray about it,” Parker stated concerning the faculty choice course of. “Wherever God is telling you, no matter God is placing in your coronary heart, hearken to that, whether or not it aligns along with your political views or not.”

RELATED: Samford College cuts ties with LGBTQ-affirming ministries amid scholar outcry